I have a very specific type of guy, and I hate it

I'm 26F, I am no model but I'm not ugly either, I have my life well put together and I don't necessarily need a relationship but I had two good and long ones and I enjoy having someone… however, I'm very specific about the kind of guy I am attracted to – it's not something out of my league, or like 6ft tall muscular etc, it's more like about general face traits, hair color, style that I find attractive, and it's so rare to find guys like that in my area.

I tried a few online datings apps and I feel like everyone is either a super fit model, that are indeed very handsome but not my type, or quite ugly and unattractive. I tried to not be so superficial and talk with guys out of my type, but honestly… it just don't work? I just prefer to be alone. I hate to be this specific.